I'll give it an 8.15 out of 10.
I highly recommend it. I've been going there for many years, much more than any other pizza place. Note: the pizza tastes the same regardless of which Rusty's you go to, EXCEPT the one on Turnpike.
I've heard that their salads are good, and their subs mediocre. I've only been present at the ordering of one sub from Rusty's, and he didn't like cheese.
It takes them about twelve minutes to cook your pizza.
As far as I know, they don't have soft crust pizza that isn't pan pizza (deep dish). The rest of my family liked it; for me it was an acquired taste.